Germany has struggled to revive its industrial economy. France has struggled to agree on a budget. Britain has struggled to lift productivity. Across all three, weak growth is proving difficult enough to reverse, with political uncertainty threatening to make matters worse.

The political consequences have been strikingly different. France has witnessed mass demonstrations and parliamentary deadlock, Germany has seen growing support for the Alternative for Germany (AfD), while Britain has experienced its own electoral upheaval.

For businesses, however, the consequences may be much the same. Uncertainty over future economic policy can make investment decisions harder to justify, particularly when economic prospects are already weak. That raises the possibility of a damaging cycle: sluggish growth fuels political dissatisfaction, while the uncertainty that follows discourages the investment needed to restore it.

When Economic Stagnation Becomes Political

Britain's Brexit vote offered an early warning of how unevenly economic shocks can shape political choices. Researchers Italo Colantone and Piero Stanig found that areas more exposed to Chinese import competition were more likely to vote Leave in 2016.1 National growth figures can conceal the difficulties facing communities where established industries have declined and better-paid employment has been slow to replace them.

Similar pressures are visible across Europe, although their political consequences differ. In France, where public debt reached 115.7 per cent of GDP in 2025, disputes over taxation and spending have become increasingly contentious.2 These tensions have spilled onto the streets. On 5th November, approximately 575,000 demonstrators took part in protests across France, according to the Interior Ministry, demanding higher wages and greater investment in public services.3 The demonstrations have placed further pressure on a government already struggling to reconcile demands for greater public spending with the need to reduce its budget deficit.

Germany's industrial weakness has coincided with growing support for the AfD, which secured 20.8 per cent of the vote in the 2025 federal election.4 Economic frustration may have contributed, but debates over immigration and distrust of established parties also matter.

Britain has experienced a similar shift in political support. Reform UK won the most seats in England's May 2026 local elections, taking 1,454 councillors, a gain of 1,452, while Labour lost 1,498.5 Public dissatisfaction with economic conditions remains widespread. An Ipsos survey in October found that 80 per cent of Britons considered the economy to be in poor condition, while 67 per cent lacked confidence that Labour's latest Budget would address the country's long-term economic problems.6 These frustrations present a growing challenge for a government already facing pressure to improve living standards, with continued economic disappointment threatening to deepen political discontent.

Why has this dissatisfaction taken different forms? France's tradition of street mobilisation makes demonstrations a familiar response to government policy, while Germany's electoral system offers dissatisfied voters another route into politics. Political culture and institutions may help explain how discontent is expressed, while fiscal pressures can intensify the disputes behind it. For businesses, the greater concern arises when those disputes leave future economic policy uncertain.

The Economic Costs of Political Uncertainty

France's budget deadlock presents a problem that extends well beyond parliament. On 4th November, lawmakers rejected the amended revenue section of the proposed 2027 budget by 458 votes to none.7 The uncertainty did not begin in November. François Bayrou's government had already collapsed following a parliamentary confidence vote in September 2025, illustrating how long France's fiscal direction had been politically contested.8 For businesses considering new investments, the prolonged budget deadlock makes it difficult to anticipate the tax regime they will face in 2027.

A company deciding whether to build or expand a factory must weigh costs against returns that may take years to materialise. Even a change in tax policy can alter those calculations considerably. Unlike everyday operating expenses, major capital investments are difficult to reverse. When the political outlook becomes unpredictable, postponing a decision can be more attractive than committing millions to a project whose profitability may depend on government policy.

Research by economists Nicholas Bloom, Scott Baker and Steven Davis has linked periods of heightened economic policy uncertainty with weaker investment and employment.9 A separate study by Brandon Julio and Youngsuk Yook (2012), examining corporate investment across 48 countries, found that firms reduced investment by approximately 4.8 per cent during national election years.10 The findings suggest that even temporary uncertainty over future policy can influence decisions made long before any legislation changes.

France offers a contemporary example, although the figures tell a more complicated story. INSEE's October 2026 estimates showed total investment falling by 0.8 per cent in the first quarter, followed by declines of 0.5 and 0.6 per cent in the second and third quarters. These figures reflect revisions to earlier estimates and cover investment across the economy, rather than businesses alone. Investment by non-financial businesses fell by 0.5, 0.1 and 0.4 per cent respectively.11 Construction weakness, financing costs and energy pressures offer alternative explanations, particularly for the first-quarter decline. The figures therefore reveal an investment problem, but cannot establish how much of it was caused by political uncertainty.

Britain's experience following the Brexit referendum provides stronger evidence of the potential costs. Research by Bloom and colleagues estimated that the Brexit process reduced UK business investment by around 11 per cent in the three years following the 2016 vote.12 Firms faced prolonged uncertainty over future trading arrangements, encouraging some to delay investment. But businesses were also preparing for the possibility of higher trade barriers, making it difficult to isolate the effects of uncertainty itself.

The consequences can extend beyond the initial investment decision. When firms scale back investment in new capacity and technology, productivity growth can suffer, limiting the scope for higher wages and stronger tax revenues. Research by Dirks and Schmidt (2024) also identifies investment as an important channel through which political instability can reduce economic output.13

Does Fiscal Room Make a Difference?

Germany should, in theory, be better placed than France to revive its economy. Germany's public debt stood at 62.8 per cent of GDP in 2025, compared with France's 115.7 per cent.2 Yet Germany's relatively healthy public finances have done little to prevent years of industrial weakness and subdued investment. The contrast raises an important question: how much of Europe's economic stagnation can really be explained by fiscal constraints?

France's position is particularly difficult. With a persistent budget deficit and mounting debt, the government faces pressure to restore confidence in its public finances while responding to demands for better public services and living standards. Every proposed adjustment risks alienating a different political constituency. The resulting parliamentary deadlock makes it harder to establish a credible fiscal strategy, leaving businesses uncertain about future taxation and public spending.

France's fiscal difficulties are also becoming increasingly apparent in bond markets. Investors concerned about rising debt and political instability have demanded higher yields on French government bonds, increasing the cost of borrowing. Britain's ten-year gilt yields have historically been higher than those on equivalent French debt, partly reflecting differences in monetary policy and the institutional support available within the eurozone. Yet that gap has narrowed considerably. By early November, British ten-year yields stood at approximately 5.1 per cent, compared with 4.7 per cent in France, leaving a difference of around 40 basis points, down from around 120 in May.14 The narrowing gap illustrates how concerns about fiscal credibility can translate into higher borrowing costs, leaving governments with less money available for investment and public services.

Germany's constitutional debt brake has historically restricted government borrowing, limiting the scope for public investment. Reforms agreed in 2025 loosened these restrictions and established a €500 billion infrastructure fund, offering an opportunity to improve Germany's transport and energy networks.15 Whether this translates into stronger private investment will depend on implementation and the wider economic outlook.

Germany's investment weakness also has explanations beyond fiscal policy. Its manufacturing sector, long a driving force behind economic growth, has come under increasing pressure from high energy costs and competition from Chinese producers.16 The automotive industry offers a particularly striking example. German manufacturers have traditionally relied on exports to China, but domestic Chinese brands are increasingly challenging their position, particularly in electric vehicles. By October 2026, German car production remained 15 per cent below its pre-pandemic level in 2019, reflecting the scale of the industry's difficulties.17

A prolonged decline in manufacturing could have serious consequences for German employment, particularly in regions heavily dependent on the automotive industry. Workers displaced from highly specialised manufacturing jobs may struggle to find comparable employment elsewhere, while retraining and the development of alternative industries could take years. Government subsidies and European trade protections may offer temporary relief, but their ability to preserve Germany's industrial competitiveness over the longer term remains uncertain.

These structural pressures complicate the relationship between political uncertainty and investment. Even with greater fiscal flexibility and more predictable government policy, businesses may remain reluctant to expand production if their long-term competitiveness is uncertain. Greater political stability would therefore offer no guarantee of economic recovery.

Britain occupies an uncomfortable position between the two. Successive governments have sought to maintain fiscal credibility through rules limiting borrowing, despite mounting pressure to improve public services and stimulate growth. The current government has committed to balancing day-to-day spending with tax revenues and placing debt on a declining trajectory relative to the economy. Yet the room for manoeuvre remains limited.

The Office for Budget Responsibility's October 2026 forecast left just £15 billion of headroom against the government's main fiscal rule for 2029-30, while rising debt interest costs have further strained the public finances.18 This creates a difficult trade-off: maintaining investor confidence requires fiscal restraint, but prolonged restrictions on spending risk delaying the improvements in infrastructure and productivity needed to strengthen economic growth.

Is There Really a Vicious Cycle?

The possibility of a self-reinforcing cycle is troubling. Weak growth fuels dissatisfaction, political uncertainty discourages investment, and falling investment makes growth harder to restore. But establishing that each stage causes the next is considerably more difficult.

Research by economists Maximilian W. Dirks and Torsten Schmidt illustrates the problem. Their 2023 working paper identified a two-way relationship between economic performance and political instability.19 However, the final study, published in 2024, found no evidence that economic growth affects political instability.13 The investment channel remained important, but the evidence for a complete feedback loop was less convincing.

Economic hardship is not the only force shaping political choices. In a 2018 study of the United States, political scientist Diana Mutz found that perceived threats to social status helped explain voting behaviour.20 Although the American findings cannot be applied directly to Europe, they caution against attributing political upheaval to weak growth alone.

Nor does every form of political unrest create the same uncertainty for businesses. A protest over living standards may have little immediate effect on investment plans, while the collapse of a government budget can leave firms unsure about future taxes and spending commitments. The distinction matters when assessing the economic consequences of instability.

What Uncertainty Costs

Political uncertainty can hold back investment, as France's budget deadlock demonstrates, but the evidence that economic stagnation consistently generates a self-reinforcing political cycle remains weaker. Germany's industrial difficulties highlight how structural pressures can persist regardless of political stability.

France's immediate fiscal uncertainty, Germany's structural industrial decline and Britain's constrained public finances illustrate the different obstacles facing Europe's recovery. Greater political stability may help restore confidence, but without addressing the economic weaknesses driving dissatisfaction, Europe's stagnation could prove far harder to escape.

Footnotes

  1. American Political Science Review, Global Competition and Brexit (opens in a new tab), May 2018.

  2. Eurostat, Euro area government deficit at 3.0% and EU at 3.1% of GDP (opens in a new tab), 21st October 2026. 2

  3. Le Monde, France takes to the streets again in massive protests over cost of living (opens in a new tab), 6th November 2026.

  4. BBC News, Germany's conservatives celebrate, but far right enjoy record result (opens in a new tab), 23rd February 2025.

  5. BBC News, England Local election results 2026 (opens in a new tab).

  6. Ipsos, Despite Strong Backing for Targeted Cost-of-Living Measures, 2 in 3 (67%) Lack Confidence That the Labour Government’s Budget Addresses the Long-Term Economic Issues Facing the Country (opens in a new tab), 31st October 2026.

  7. POLITICO, French National Assembly unanimously rejects budget bill (opens in a new tab), 5th November 2026.

  8. The Guardian, François Bayrou ousted as French PM after losing confidence vote (opens in a new tab), 8th September 2025.

  9. Quarterly Journal of Economics, Measuring Economic Policy Uncertainty (opens in a new tab), 1st November 2016.

  10. The Journal of Finance, Political Uncertainty and Corporate Investment Cycles (opens in a new tab), February 2012.

  11. INSEE, In Q3 2026, GDP slightly declined (-0.1% after 0.0%) (opens in a new tab), 30th October 2026.

  12. Bank of England, The Impact of Brexit on UK Firms (opens in a new tab), 30th August 2019.

  13. European Journal of Political Economy, Political Instability and Economic Growth: Causation and Transmission (opens in a new tab), December 2024. 2

  14. Bank of England Database, Yield from British Government Securities, 10 year Nominal Par Yield (opens in a new tab).Banque de France Webstat, Constant maturity rate 10 years (opens in a new tab).

  15. European Commission, The Potential Economic Impact of the Reform of Germany's Fiscal Framework (opens in a new tab), 19th May 2025.

  16. OECD, Strengthening Fiscal Policy and Continuing Structural Reforms to Revive Economic Growth (opens in a new tab), 12th June 2025.

  17. German Association of the Automotive Industry (VDA), Production and Market in October 2026 (opens in a new tab), 3rd November 2026.

  18. Office for Budget Responsibility, Economic and Fiscal Outlook - October 2026 (opens in a new tab), 28th October 2026.

  19. Ruhr Economic Papers, The Relationship between Political Instability and Economic Growth in Advanced Economies: Empirical Evidence from a Panel VAR and a Dynamic Panel FE-IV Analysis (opens in a new tab), February 2023.

  20. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Status Threat, Not Economic Hardship, Explains the 2016 Presidential Vote (opens in a new tab), 8th May 2018.