Nvidia has spent the AI boom becoming almost impossible for the market to ignore. So when Jensen Huang stepped down and shares fell sharply, the obvious assumption was that the S&P 500 would follow. It barely did.
That disconnect is now the more interesting story. Nvidia is facing questions over leadership, governance and the sustainability of the AI trade, yet the wider market has remained surprisingly resilient. This article will first look at what has pushed Nvidia into crisis, before asking why America’s benchmark index seems far less dependent on its biggest company than investors might expect.
When Nvidia Loses Its North Star
Nvidia’s selloff did not begin with Jensen Huang’s resignation, but his departure has poured petrol on a fire that was already burning. Shares fell 6.5% on 10th November, putting the company on course to erase more than $470 billion of market value in just two sessions as investors reacted to an internal investigation surrounding Jensen Huang and his relationship with Alice Huang, whom US officials allege is a Chinese spy, generating growing anxiety across the AI trade1. By the time his resignation was confirmed two days later, Nvidia fell more than 10% further in pre-market trading, threatening to push its total market capitalisation below $4 trillion2.
The catalyst is unusually messy for a company normally discussed through GPU shipments and data-centre demand. Huang stepped down after admitting an extramarital affair with a woman whom US officials allege is a Chinese intelligence operative, an allegation Beijing denies. Reports of a second relationship with a senior Nvidia employee who reported to him added a much more conventional corporate-governance problem to an already uncomfortable geopolitical one.
The bigger concern for shareholders is what happens after Jensen Huang leaves. Nvidia has spent more than three decades being built around its co-founder. Jensen Huang oversaw more than 60 direct reports, while four senior executives sat at roughly equal standing beneath him and, until this week, the board did not even have a chairman3. Nvidia may have built the world’s most valuable semiconductor ecosystem, but apparently nobody remembered to write the succession plan.
CFO Colette Kress has taken over on an interim basis, while Kress and senior engineer Ian Buck are regarded as leading internal candidates for the permanent role. Both are experienced, but replacing Huang means more than finding somebody capable of delivering an earnings call. His relationships with customers, governments and AI companies became part of Nvidia’s competitive advantage.
That is why I suspect the downside may not yet be exhausted. Nvidia’s technology roadmap has not disappeared overnight, but investors are no longer pricing only semiconductor demand. They are pricing execution risk at a company whose operating structure revolved unusually heavily around one man. Until the board can convince markets that Nvidia has found sustainable leadership rather than a temporary caretaker, the share price may have difficulty finding its floor.
Nvidia Falls, The S&P 500 Holds
Given Nvidia’s importance to the S&P 500, the first instinct is that a double-digit collapse in its share price should drag the entire index down with it. The maths certainly points that way. Nvidia represented roughly 7.3% of the S&P 500 at the beginning of November. Holding every other company constant, a 10% fall in Nvidia should therefore knock roughly 0.73 percentage points from the index. A 14% collapse would contribute just over 1 percentage point of downside on its own.
Yet while Nvidia fell more than 10% in pre-market trading following Huang’s resignation, S&P 500 futures were down only around 0.5%. Somewhere inside the remaining 92.7% of the index, investors were quietly putting the money back to work.
The first reason is that Jensen Huang’s resignation threatens Nvidia considerably more than it threatens demand for AI. Data centres still need GPUs, hyperscalers are still building infrastructure and corporate appetite for computing power has not disappeared because Nvidia has misplaced its succession plan. In fact, AMD and Broadcom rose as Nvidia fell, with investors betting that both could steal market share from a distracted competitor. The AI trade may therefore be rotating rather than collapsing. If Nvidia sells one fewer chip, Wall Street appears increasingly willing to ask who sells it instead.
The wider earnings picture is also doing plenty of heavy lifting. With 88% of S&P 500 companies having reported third-quarter results by early November, 84% had beaten earnings expectations, while aggregate earnings were running 31.4% above the same quarter last year. Even more importantly, all eleven sectors were reporting year-on-year earnings growth4. Nvidia may be having an awful week, but corporate America generally is not.
There are signs that market leadership has broadened as well. During October, the equal-weighted S&P 500 actually gained 5.0% while the traditional market-cap-weighted index fell 0.9%, with nine of eleven sectors advancing. That is almost exactly the sort of rotation required for the market to absorb a shock from one of its giants.
But by no means would I declare Nvidia irrelevant just yet. Technology still accounts for close to 39% of the S&P 500. If Huang’s departure remains a company-specific governance disaster, the wider market can probably stomach it. If it causes customers to delay spending, damages confidence in AI infrastructure or becomes the catalyst for a broader reassessment of the AI boom, the arithmetic becomes much less forgiving.
For now, Nvidia has fallen and Wall Street has shrugged. Perhaps the S&P 500 is finally learning that one company, however enormous, is still only one company.
Footnotes
-
Reuters, Nvidia selloff deepens, adding to AI jitters (opens in a new tab), 10th November 2026.
-
Reuters, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigns in blow to AI boom he helped foster (opens in a new tab), 12th November 2026.
-
Reuters Breakingviews, Jensen Huang’s fall can shatter Nvidia’s kingdom (opens in a new tab), 12th November 2026.
-
FactSet, S&P 500 Earnings Season Update (opens in a new tab), 6th November 2026.