Written on 17th November 2026, before Nathan Cofnas's talk at Oriel College. The story is still developing.
On 5th August, Jason Arday resigned as professor of sociology at Cambridge, hours after the university said it had received new information about his qualifications and honorary appointments and would open a separate investigation.1 Nine days later he was found dead. Police said the death was being treated as unexpected but not suspicious.2 Nothing in the reporting establishes why it happened, and this article does not suggest a cause.
This evening, Nathan Cofnas, who made some of the plagiarism claims against Arday, is due to speak at Oriel College, Oxford. More than 30,000 people have signed a petition to cancel the talk, and over 170 academics have signed a letter backing the college for holding it.3
That raises a question people on both sides are answering with great confidence: does this story show that systemic racism is still shaping British universities? The honest answer is that the wider evidence points that way in places, but this case cannot settle it.
What is actually known
The plagiarism concerns did not begin with Cofnas. Jack Grove, a reporter at Times Higher Education, says he wrote a 63-page report alleging that Arday's PhD used substantial material from a 2009 thesis without proper citation, and sent evidence to Cambridge and Liverpool John Moores University (LJMU), which awarded the doctorate.4
Cofnas, who calls himself a "race realist", published his own accusations on Substack in July. Questions were also raised about personal claims, such as running 30 marathons in 35 days. LJMU did not uphold the plagiarism allegations and put the issues down to "honest and reasonable error". In a Times interview Arday admitted "mistakes" but said he had been wrongly portrayed as a fraud, and alleged the campaign against him was racially motivated. Cambridge had called the claims "a vile campaign", before opening its own inquiry.1
Cambridge's inquiries had not reported when he resigned, so as far as the reporting shows, the questions about his CV never reached a formal finding.
The case that race shaped the scrutiny
Arday's supporters argue that the campaign was never neutral. Byline Times reports that the early plagiarism allegations came from Dave Harris and Martyn Hammersley, both critics of anti-racist scholarship, and that Harris annotated one of Arday's articles on racial inequality with the comment "What liberal shit". It says Cofnas's Substack post started a campaign followed by more than 200 articles, and quotes one academic asking why Arday alone was singled out when his co-authors faced no similar allegations. It also reports that some academics, "especially those of colour", feared unwarranted scrutiny and declined to speak publicly.5
Cofnas's own record gives that reading some weight. Cherwell reports that he was dismissed by Emmanuel College, Cambridge, after a blog post claiming that Black academics would "approach zero" under a meritocracy.3
The statistics are stronger evidence than any single case. In 2018-19, HESA figures showed 140 Black professors among more than 21,000 in UK universities, or 0.7%.6 Advance HE's report on 2022-23 data found that only 3.8% of UK Black academics are professors, and that Black professors remain the most underrepresented group. It also found 29.0% of UK Black, Asian and minority ethnic academics on fixed-term contracts, compared with 23.3% of White academics.7
Those figures describe patterns, not one man's career, and patterns are what "systemic" means: disadvantages that arise from how institutions work, whatever any individual intends. They come from different years, and the fixed-term figure covers all minority ethnic academics rather than Black academics alone, so they are not a complete picture.
The case against reading it as racism
None of that proves the scrutiny of Arday was racially motivated. Grove, who raised concerns well before Cofnas published, describes his emails as polite and factual and says his enquiries were legitimate and in the public interest. His account does not claim race played any part. He argues instead that the institutions were too slow, and that Cambridge's early position, that LJMU should handle the PhD question, was inadequate for too long.4
Cofnas's defenders make a different argument. Writing in Quillette on 14th August, Rosalind Arden said Cambridge treated its two scholars inconsistently: "One scholar was punished for an opinion; the other was protected despite misconduct that objective methods could verify." She says Cambridge's internal investigation found no breach of law or free speech rules in Cofnas's case, and that a 2026 county court ruling upheld his termination while calling his expression "objectionable".2 That essay is advocacy, and should be read as one side's case. Cherwell does report, though, that a Cambridge internal investigation found his comments did not constitute discrimination or harassment.3
The other side has evidence too. LJMU did not uphold the plagiarism claims, and Byline Times says Taylor & Francis corrected one of Arday's papers without finding plagiarism or fabrication.5
Both sets of claims can be partly true. The concerns about Arday's work came from different people, some of them journalists following routine practice and some openly hostile to the field he worked in. A hostile campaign does not make every question baseless, and a legitimate question does not make every motive clean.
What the Oxford row adds
Tonight's talk, "Does DEI undermine higher education?", is the same disagreement at a different scale. Oriel's JCR approved a statement by 90.61% of voting students calling Cofnas's views "despicable" while accepting that the college is legally required to host him. Oxford's Philosophy Faculty Board said the university's free speech commitment "does not indicate endorsement of Dr Cofnas's views", while the university's Diversity Officer said free speech "does not extend" to violations of human rights and anti-harassment legislation.3 The petition's supporters argue that "Ideas platformed at Oxford do not stay in the lecture theatre."8
The fair verdict
Those who say racism still shapes British universities are right that the structural evidence is hard to dismiss. Black academics are heavily underrepresented among professors, and the figures show gaps in contract security too. Someone who is one of very few in a field can reasonably feel that every mistake is read as proof of something bigger.
Those who say the Arday case shows no such thing are right that a hostile critic, or one with controversial views, does not make every concern invalid. The first questions came from a journalist using routine channels, Cambridge's own investigation found Cofnas's comments were not discrimination, and Cambridge opened a new inquiry of its own.
What the case does show is how badly institutions handle disputes like this. As Grove argues, the process was slow and defensive, serious questions about one man's work stayed unresolved for months, and they may now never be settled.
So is systemic racism still a problem in UK higher education? On the numbers, the evidence says yes. Does the Arday case prove it? No, and it can't. The strongest version of that argument rests on the data, not on one person's story.
Footnotes
-
Al Jazeera, Cambridge professor Jason Arday quits amid plagiarism allegations (opens in a new tab), 6th August 2026. 2
-
Quillette, Institutional Failures in the Garden of Great Intellects (opens in a new tab), 14th August 2026. 2
-
Cherwell, Nathan Cofnas to speak at Oriel College: A summary of events (opens in a new tab), 17th November 2026. 2 3 4
-
Times Higher Education, I was reported to police over the Arday case. I was just doing my job (opens in a new tab), 5th August 2026. 2
-
Byline Times, Jason Arday: The Story Behind the Story of The Times' 'Impossible Data' (opens in a new tab), 10th September 2026. 2
-
The Guardian (via Yahoo News Canada), Fewer than 1% of UK university professors are black, figures show (opens in a new tab), 27th February 2020.
-
Advance HE, Equality in higher education: staff statistical report 2024 (opens in a new tab), 14th November 2024.
-
Al Jazeera, Thousands demand cancellation of Nathan Cofnas talk at Oxford University (opens in a new tab), 17th November 2026.