It has long been known that climate change poses a serious threat to economies and humanity as a whole. It was in 2006, when the Stern Review was released, that climate change was described as “the greatest market failure the world has ever seen.”1 But real progress still feels far away. The main problem is the greenhouse gas externality, in which most of the consequences of pollution fall not on the polluter but on others, including future generations.2 As the effects of greenhouse gases are external to the market, there is no incentive for consumers and firms to decrease emissions, leading to the over-exploitation of the environment that we have seen for the past two centuries.
The solution, in theory, is therefore to price emissions, as this internalises the social cost that pollution imposes on others, and we have seen this through the introduction of carbon taxes such as Norway’s €146.23 ($169.71) tax per tonne of carbon emissions.3 This could even lead to the market innovating and creating more sustainable solutions, moving us closer to those net-zero targets.
For decades, we have assumed that climate action is possible with the right policy and government intervention, but this has led policymakers to often put it off until the right moment. Unfortunately, creating incentives strong enough to create real behavioural change is just not this simple.
Mark Carney, the Canadian Prime Minister, understands full well that pricing carbon is the most efficient solution, but unfortunately, this isn’t so popular with the public.4 A Pigouvian tax isn’t as simple to implement in reality as it is in theory: the second that such taxes drive up prices, politicians become wary. In addition to this, putting the theory into practice is far from straightforward. While the tax should reflect the exact cost of CO2 on society, this cannot simply be pinned down, as it falls on the whole world long into the future, so any estimates depend on many assumptions. This leads to a value judgement: how we value future generations compared to life today, and this has led to discount rates which prioritise the present over the future, risking short-termism.5
The increase in heating bills hits voters straight away, and with a large part of a politician’s job to win over voters at the next election, supporting inflationary carbon taxes in many cases is a significant risk.6 The problem with climate action is therefore clear: the costs of acting arrive long before the benefits.
A brief history
The first World Climate Conference was held in 1979, and after James Hansen told the US Senate that humans were warming the planet in 1988, the IPCC was created.7 Soon after, the first UN climate treaty was adopted in 1992, but global emissions kept rising. Going into the Paris Agreement in 2015, many were hopeful that real change could be made. It was supposed to be a symbol of cooperation, a sign that progress could be made when long-term survival outweighed short-term politics.8
In 2026, however, things don’t seem so positive. Cooperation between countries has fallen, especially as the United States officially exited the Paris climate agreement for the second time on 27th January 2026. But just because the politics is broken doesn’t mean the economics is. The first step of climate action was always going to be creating cost-competitive renewable energy that could be fully integrated into the world economy. Through effective policy, in the decade leading up to Paris, governments, especially in Europe, made renewables a genuine alternative. As production scaled up, prices plunged, and they now in many cases out-compete those of fossil fuels.8 So just as we saw with renewable energy, if the correct policy is introduced, it could drive investment and create incentives for real change.
Why does climate inaction persist?
The Coase theorem, from the 1991 Nobel Prize winner Ronald Coase, explains when the market can fix an externality on its own, and why it cannot here. Coase realised that if property rights are clear and transferable, and the transaction costs of finding, negotiating with and contracting with the other parties are zero, then both parties will bargain to an efficient outcome, creating a solution that demands no government intervention.9 Climate change, largely driven by an externality, meets neither condition. In reality, nobody owns the atmosphere, and there would be billions of victims and polluters to negotiate costs with, many of whom belong to future generations whose interests are discounted against our own, so the market can’t create the efficient outcome on its own, and something else has to create the incentive. Creating the missing price signal is the typical answer, but evidence suggests that the problem runs much deeper than this.
While there has been a strong focus on methods of adaptation and mitigation, policymakers are failing to look at why inaction persists, particularly the incentives behind inaction. The answer, the writers of the 2025 research paper ‘Addressing climate inaction as our greatest threat to sustainable development’ argue, isn’t that humans don’t care or we don’t have the technology; it’s that the way the economy is set up makes it hard for everyone to act.1 In other words, climate inaction is not just market-based; it is systemic. This means that the weaknesses run through the whole economy, so pricing one externality is not enough. The four main causes of this are:
-
Most individuals and firms remain focused on their own narrow market interests, despite the shared threat of climate change. Many also doubt that government intervention can fix the problem, and that lack of confidence makes collective action less likely.
-
The central flaw in the system’s design is that immediate gains are prioritised over the system’s long-term maintenance, which results in sustainable solutions being undervalued. This ultimately leads to multiple missed opportunities for climate action.
-
A major part of development economics is the belief that when markets are effectively managed, they will achieve the best outcomes for society, but there are currently too few market systems which will incentivise individuals to invest in the political, economic, and social actions which must take place.
-
Additionally, climate policies often fail to consider the role of individuals. When their behaviour is oversimplified, policies overlook the part organisations and people play.
Concern about climate change outstrips willingness to pay for it
What could stimulate climate action?
The environmental crisis will not be solved by price signals and aligning the aims of individuals and the private sector with those of society alone: it will require individual behavioural change driven by huge incentives. Authors Eric Lonergan and Corinne Sawers have a name for these incentives, “extreme positive incentives for change” (EPICs).10 By creating immediate incentives, we could create the real shift needed in order to decrease reliance on polluting technology, as seen in the Boiler Upgrade Scheme in England and Wales, where households can get a £7,500 grant towards an air-to-water heat pump.11
In consumer research from BCG, over 90% of consumers would be unwilling to pay a “green premium.”12 Therefore, it is the job of government to ensure that the consumer does not take the hit, and a proposed way of doing this is to give rebates to citizens. This could lead to most households receiving more in ‘carbon dividends’ than they lose due to increased energy prices, leaving them at a net surplus.13 The carbon tax could start lower initially, to soften the blow, but gradually increase, leaving time for the market to innovate new sustainable solutions and adapt until it reaches the level needed to meet climate targets. This could solve the major cause of inaction: a lack of political motivation due to no immediate gain.
Another solution that can provide a means to act is tradable pollution permits. While there is no property right for the atmosphere, and hence no market for rights to pollution, tradable permits can create this market. By setting a cap and enabling polluters to trade among themselves, the invisible hand of the market will allocate the cuts efficiently, as firms that can cut emissions cheaply will, and will also sell their permits to firms with higher costs.14 This is effective not just because it encourages innovation, but because the government can fix the quantity of pollution. Not only does this integrate pollution into the market, it actively encourages firms to use renewable sources of energy.
Why politics is the real barrier
Ultimately, government intervention will be fundamental in driving real change, but its main role will be introducing regulation in the form of tradable pollution permits, creating strong incentives through rebates, and driving societal awareness.
As time goes on, humanity cannot wait to act, as the price of inaction is simply too great. But change is difficult in a world driven by the now. Some firms resist it because it threatens their revenue, and consumers are already struggling enough with growing inflation. In the UK, the Conservative Party leader, Kemi Badenoch, has pledged to scrap the UK Emissions Trading Scheme and the carbon border adjustment mechanism if her party returns to power, arguing it would protect jobs in energy-intensive industries: a clear reminder that immediate gains are prioritised over long-term maintenance.15
The systems can be created, but what is really needed is political coherence and long-termism, and with the world's largest economy having withdrawn from the Paris Agreement and rolling back its climate regulation, that will be difficult.
Footnotes
-
Global Environmental Change, Addressing climate inaction as our greatest threat to sustainable development (opens in a new tab), May 2025. 2
-
Grantham Research Institute on climate change and the environment, Why do economists describe climate change as a market failure? (opens in a new tab), 21st March 2014.
-
Tax Foundation Europe, Carbon Taxes in Europe, 2026 (opens in a new tab), 29th June 2026.
-
The Economist, The climate needs a politics of the possible (opens in a new tab), 31st July 2025.
-
Resources for the Future, Social Cost of Carbon 101 (opens in a new tab), 13th March 2025.
-
Financial Times, Real carbon taxes are the next big political battle (opens in a new tab), 23rd September 2021.
-
United Nations, Climate negotiations timeline (opens in a new tab), 20th June 2018.
-
TIME, 10 Years After the Paris Climate Deal: What the World Got Right, Wrong, and What Comes Next (opens in a new tab), 15th December 2025. 2
-
Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, The Prize in Economics 1991 - Press release (opens in a new tab), 15th October 1991.
-
The Economist, Have economists led the world's environmental policies astray? (opens in a new tab), 26th March 2022.
-
Fortune, The path to net zero that doesn't punish consumers, businesses, or politicians (opens in a new tab), 6th January 2025.
-
Climate Leadership Council, Economists' Statement on Carbon Dividends (opens in a new tab), 17th January 2019.
-
US Environmental Protection Agency, Why Do Emissions Trading Programs Work? (opens in a new tab), 16th March 2016.
-
BBC News, Tories pledge to scrap carbon taxes on industry (opens in a new tab), 2nd April 2026.