For generations, the standard advice handed down to teenagers has been simple: treat university as an investment in the future. The argument seems straightforward. Students pay for higher education, acquire skills and qualifications, and expect to earn more over their working lives. At the heart of this argument lies the ‘graduate premium’, the long-observed earnings advantage that degree holders have over those who enter the workforce straight at eighteen. Analysis from organisations like the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) has supported this thesis for decades, tracking lifetime earnings differences between graduates and non-graduates that run comfortably into hundreds of thousands of pounds.
The latest IFS estimates, published on 25th June 2026, still find that university on average can lead to better pay in the future. But the same research finds that around 24% of graduates will not gain financially from attending at all.1 For students choosing whether to go to university now, what stands out is how unevenly the premium is distributed. The generic question of whether university ‘pays’ has outlived its usefulness. The real issue is far more specific.
For whom, for which degree, and compared with what alternative can it be rationalised economically?
The cost of a degree
For the 2026/27 academic year, the maximum undergraduate tuition fee in England has risen to £9,790 a year.2 Popular debate routinely misjudges what university actually costs because attention falls only on explicit accounting bills. It is tempting to look at a three-year undergraduate course, note roughly £30,000 in tuition fees, and add the Higher Education Policy Institute’s Minimum Income Standard, which puts three-year living costs at around £61,000 outside London and £77,000 in London, to conclude that a degree costs around £90,000, or over £100,000 in London.3
Rent, food, and energy are not, in themselves, costs of university, since an eighteen-year-old who goes straight into employment must still pay to live. Only the additional cost of studying, such as tuition and any premium on student housing, is a genuine economic cost of the degree. At the same time, the sum leaves out the largest cost of all, which is the income given up while studying.
Opportunity cost. Signing away three years to a lecture hall means choosing three years of little or no income from full-time employment. While a university student is navigating the negative cash flows of student housing, their peer who stepped straight into employment at eighteen starts earning and accumulating real workplace experience immediately. This does not mean the university student has made the wrong choice, but if higher education is an investment, the ultimate return has to be measured against the value of the alternative life that was given up to make that investment happen.
The average return
Once individual differences, taxation, and student-loan repayments are factored in, the estimated net financial return from starting an undergraduate degree is considerably smaller than the headline earnings gap might suggest. The IFS estimates an average net lifetime financial return of around £90,000 for women and £109,000 for men.1 These figures are discounted. A pound earned at forty is not worth the same as a pound earned at eighteen, so the IFS follows the government’s Green Book approach and discounts future earnings. The choice makes a surprisingly large difference. Adjusting only for inflation, the same estimates rise to £256,000 for women and £371,000 for men.
Less than a third of the raw earnings gap survives as a net gain
Averages, however, conceal. The same analysis suggests that around 19% of women and 31% of men may be financially worse off over their lifetimes as a result of going to university. So while university is a good financial investment on average, a significant minority of students will not receive a positive financial return.
Men face a wider spread of outcomes from a degree than women
Differences between degrees
There is no single premium. A degree in medicine or economics represents a fundamentally different proposition from a course with much lower earnings prospects. The IFS finds that medicine and economics offer the highest net lifetime returns, at over £400,000 on average, while subjects including creative arts, philosophy, and languages produce low or negative average returns.1 The comparison therefore should not simply be university versus no university.
Even within a subject, averages hide radically different careers. Economics is a clear example. Among economics graduates with positive earnings at age 37, the IFS found median earnings of approximately £68,000 for women and £90,000 for men, yet the highest-earning 10% earned at least approximately £164,000 and £263,000 respectively.1 Knowing that economics has a high average financial return tells a prospective student something useful about the aggregate labour market, but it does not tell them what they personally will earn. Academic performance, location, sector, economic conditions, and luck will all matter. The return does not sit inside the degree certificate; it emerges from what the individual does with it and the opportunities available to them.
Human capital and signalling
This leads into the debate between human capital and signalling theory. On the human capital view, university raises productivity by providing technical knowledge, analytical skills, and specialist expertise that employers are willing to pay for.4 Signalling theory offers a different explanation: employers cannot easily observe someone’s ability, persistence, or conscientiousness when they first apply for a job, and a degree signals, at the very least, that the applicant has been able to meet certain academic demands.5 In reality, separating them into a neat binary choice is a mistake; a degree can make people more capable while also signalling qualities they already possessed.
The signalling view also raises a concern about credential inflation. As higher education participation has expanded, degrees may have lost some of their scarcity value. If a degree becomes a basic requirement for jobs that do not actually require degree-level knowledge, it functions less like evidence of specialist skills and more like a blunt screening device. Rational firms fill entry-level jobs with graduates due to the safety net that they can plausibly succeed in the role. However, this can have the capacity to displace equally capable non-graduates and divert resources from more productive uses. The damage can be both individual and collective. Workers incur the costs of higher education simply to stay competitive, rather than to gain useful skills, whilst society spends on education without having an equal gain in productivity. On the margin, where the costs are highest and the skills gained are the lowest, this poses the greatest disadvantage. If this occurs, the likely outcome is credential inflation without the same gain in skills, and more graduates in jobs that do not use degrees, leading to greater inefficiency.
Student loans and risk
For the individual, the downside is cushioned by the progressive design of England’s student loan system, which looks entirely different from a conventional commercial loan. Under Plan 5, graduates repay 9% of their earnings above a £25,000 threshold. If income falls below that line, repayments stop, and any outstanding balance is written off 40 years after the April in which repayments first fall due.6 Students can therefore leave university with very large nominal debts while the taxpayer absorbs the cost of balances that are never fully repaid. Even so, the exchequer gains on average, by an estimated £48,000 for each woman and £107,000 for each man who enrols, mainly through higher tax receipts, although it makes a loss on around 40% of degrees.1 The financial risk is shared, with a high-earning graduate repaying more and a lower earner repaying relatively little, yet this risk-sharing does not make the underlying opportunity cost vanish.
Non-financial benefits
None of this means that the value of university can be reduced to salary. Higher education can provide knowledge, independence, friendships, professional networks, and access to regulated occupations. It can also produce benefits for society, such as research, innovation, and a more highly educated workforce, that reach well beyond the individual graduate. These wider benefits mean that the social return to education can exceed the financial return captured by the individual, which is one reason the state continues to support higher education even when it will not recover the full cost of every student’s education through repayments. There is also a more personal point: a student may choose a degree out of pure intellectual curiosity and because they enjoy learning. Those things hold value even if they cannot be neatly converted into pounds and pence.
Conclusion
Rather than a guarantee of success, university should be viewed as an investment under uncertainty. At 17 or 18, nobody knows exactly what the return will be. Higher education has not stopped being valuable, but the phrase ‘graduate premium’ makes the return sound much more certain and uniform than it really is. A degree can be an excellent investment for one person and a poor decision for another. Judging which requires looking beyond university prospectuses and open-day marketing to weigh the probability of achieving the expected earnings, the direct costs, student-loan repayments, three years outside the labour market, and the value of the alternatives being given up. The economic decision is not whether university is ‘worth it’ in the abstract. It is whether this investment, by this student, in this degree, is likely to outperform the next-best alternative. A degree can open many doors, but its value depends on which doors it opens, what it costs to reach them, and what a student gives up along the way.
Footnotes
-
Institute for Fiscal Studies, New estimates of the impact of undergraduate degrees on lifetime earnings (opens in a new tab), 25th June 2026. 2 3 4 5
-
Higher Education Policy Institute, A Minimum Income Standard for Students (opens in a new tab), 12th August 2025.
-
National Bureau of Economic Research, Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis, with Special Reference to Education (opens in a new tab), 1964.
-
The Quarterly Journal of Economics, Job Market Signaling (opens in a new tab), August 1973.
-
GOV.UK, Repaying your student loan: What you pay (opens in a new tab).GOV.UK, Repaying your student loan: When your student loan gets written off or cancelled (opens in a new tab).